So, one of, if not THE most famous kenshi of modern times, Miyazaki Masahiro sensei, passed his hachidan exam a week ago in Kyoto, at the age of 46, on his first attempt, further cementing his god like status. Especially with foreigners who don’t know any other ones. Fnar.
Anyway, someone uploaded his gradings on to youtube, see for yourself:
1st Round (left side)
2nd Round (Far side)
(you fight 4 times if you get that far in the hachidan exam, though most are cut after 2, roughly 90% or so) So there it is for the world to see the master……and I’m not entirely sure how he passed.
I know, I know. You’re saying, HOW COULD YOU! or THE VILLAINY! Or maybe something more simple like YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT YOU’RE TALKING ABOUT!! And you’d probably be quite right, after all, I’m only a lowly 4th dan, he’s just passed 4 higher than that (amongst his other achievements), and was done so by two seperate panels of hachidan hanshi sensei, but like anyone else I’m entitled to my opinion (which you obviously want to read!! Yeah) so fuck off. But why do think that maybe he shouldn’t have passed (there, I said it!)?
The first and biggest thing that struck me was that it seemed really forced, not really natural. I’ve watched MUCH of Miyazaki sensei’s shiai, one of my favourite techniques is one I first saw him do on video, but this was an obviously restrained Miyazaki compared to the confident one I’d seen in videos. And the zanshin after his menuchi doesn’t add to the image either, like he’s fully aware that it needs to be done, which is why it’s there, as opposed to something more fluid. It really seems to me like he is holding his natural self back, and a lot. Take a look at the second fight of the second round, because this one in particular looks like he got at least moderately owned because of this.
The other really noticeable thing is that he just doesn’t appear that “graceful” through out. Again, maybe this is my lowly 4th dan mind speaking (of course it is!!) but I’ve always thought that hachidan’s, passed or grading hopefuls or otherwise, need an element of gracefulness about their kendo, regardless of their style. Certainly the great majority of what I have had the opportunity to see and practise with, including the younger ones, had at least an element of this, but I was really struggling to see it in the videos. Again, maybe I am wrong, but take a look for yourself. For me I think it is directly linked to what I said above, about having to hold back too much, and restrain himself.
That then brings a question about gradings in general that I have long thought about, really for years, in my own grading persuits: If your own natural kendo is not fit to pass, but kendo that you do specifically for the sole function of passing a grading is, is that right? For you? For the grade? I’m sure you can guess from what I have written so far in this post is that I believe No, it is not enough, purely because it’s not really your kendo that you are doing at the grading, it is what you are aware the grading panel want for a textbook pass. But if the general picture of your kendo outside of the grading is not what you do in the grading, again, is that right? Some people are simply happy to have the grade, and that’s up to them, of course, because we are all in this thing for different reasons and goals. But for me, I want the kind I do all the time to be under scrutiny, not the kendo that the book says will pass the grading. For me, this is a far more natural path up the grading ladder, but like I say, that’s just me.
So back to Miyazaki sensei. Well, I could say more (like he does almost exclusively men, or doesn’t really control his opponent enough to not get stuck on a kensen several times, including his shotachi in one of them which is arguably the most important cut in the whole jitsugi – the start of the second clip especially) but I’ll let you watch the videos and decide for yourself if it was his kendo or his name that passed the grading.
On the flip side, maybe I was expecting too much? Hoping to see something special given what he has done in pretty much everything else he’s entered? But I’m not sure…
I’m only saying what others are thinking….